Posted inFeature, Lismore, Regional Development

Data centre on planning drawing divides Lismore councillors

A site plan shows a possible data centre, although council says no development application has been submitted or approved. Source: Planning Proposal – 245 Wyrallah Road, via Lismore City Council

A data centre shown on a planning drawing has fuelled debate over 245 Wyrallah
Road – despite council confirming no application to build one has been submitted.

Lismore councillors have rejected a move to reverse an earlier decision to progress a
rezoning proposal at Monaltrie. The proposal has raised concerns about industrial development and environmental impacts.

The 10 November vote follows a unanimous decision by nine councillors on the 13 October
to advance the proposal towards the NSW Government’s Gateway process. Among the supporting documents is a proposed site drawing showing several potential industrial buildings, including one labelled “DATA CENTRE”.

No data centre application submitted

The proposal covers approximately 43.69 hectares at 245 Wyrallah Road, currently zoned
RU1 Primary Production.

It seeks to rezone about 10 hectares for medium-density housing, such as townhouses and
low-rise apartments, six hectares for general industrial use and 27 hectares for
environmental conservation.

The proposed E4 General Industrial zoning could allow a data centre, subject to further
approvals.

In a written statement to North Coast Times, a council spokesperson confirmed the data
centre was only one potential use identified in the applicant’s documents.

“Lismore City Council has not received or approved a development application for a data
centre on Wyrallah Road,” the spokesperson said.

“This decision does not approve any specific development or land use on the site.”

Council said its October decision allowed the rezoning proposal to progress towards a
Gateway determination, not the approval of any specific development.

Any future project would require a separate application and assessment, including
consideration of community submissions.

Three councillors challenge decision


At the 10 November meeting, Cr Virginia Waters and Cr Adam Guise moved to overturn the
October decision, with Cr Harper Dalton-Earls joining them in support.

Cr Dalton-Earls had voted in favour of progressing the proposal in October, while Cr Waters
and Cr Guise had not participated in that vote.

The rescission motion was defeated eight votes to three, leaving the original decision in
place.

Cr Waters raised concerns during the meeting.

“I have concerns about the appropriateness of rezoning this land for industrial and medium
density residential purposes, particularly given the environmental characteristics of the site,
its location and the potential impacts,” she told councillors.

Cr Waters said she supported appropriate development, including housing and employment
opportunities, but believed it needed to occur in suitable locations with proper consideration
of environmental constraints, sustainability, and community impacts.

A future data centre could face state assessment

“Then there’s the issue of a potential data centre, which has been identified in the planning
proposal documentation,” Cr Waters said during the meeting.

“This raises incredible questions for our community around energy and water consumption.”

Council officers confirmed a data centre could be considered under the proposed industrial
zoning, but any project would require separate assessment.

Under NSW planning rules, a data centre consuming more than 15 megawatts of power
would be assessed as State Significant Development, with the application determined by the NSW Planning Minister or Independent Planning Commission.

Smaller projects may be assessed by a regional planning panel or council, depending on
their investment value.

In written answers tabled at the November meeting, council also confirmed that it does not
have a specific policy on data centres.

Housing needs versus environmental concerns

Speaking to North Coast Times, Cr Jasmine Knight-Smith, who opposed the rescission
motion, said Lismore’s housing shortage drove her support for progressing the rezoning.

“I want housing there. And I also want medium-density housing,” she said.

“We need to make the best use of space that we can, and create places for people to live.”

Lismore City Councillor Jasmine Knight-Smith supports progressing the rezoning proposal, citing the need for more housing. Image: Supplied


The site’s proximity to Lismore’s CBD makes it suitable for additional housing, according to
Cr Knight-Smith.

Cr Knight-Smith also raised concerns about where residents of temporary flood housing would live when the site is cleared for permanent development.


“And where do we put those people? We just need houses,” she said.

While acknowledging concerns about landslip risks and the nearby nature reserve, Cr
Knight-Smith hoped these issues would be examined during the Gateway process and later
assessments.

She described the data centre in the illustrative material as an example of what might be
possible under the proposed zoning, rather than a confirmed development.

“I don’t know why they decided to put a data centre in there,” she said, while noting that data centres can be proposed on industrial-zoned land elsewhere in Lismore as well.

She stressed she would only personally support a future data centre if it used recycled water and standalone renewable energy.

Community concerns


Public speakers at the 10 November meeting also questioned the potential impact of
development on nearby bushland, wildlife corridors, and residential areas.

One speaker raised concerns about a proposed road cutting through a potential wildlife
corridor between Wilson Nature Reserve and the nearby botanic gardens.

Another questioned community consultation and the possible environmental and
infrastructure demands of a future data centre.

What happens next

Council documents identify Ardill Payne as the consultant that submitted the proposal. A
landowner consent form submitted with the application names Waterview Residence Pty Ltd as the landowner.

The defeated rescission motion leaves the proposal on course for a Gateway determination
by the NSW Government.

If the proposal proceeds to public exhibition, residents will be able to make submissions.
Under council’s October resolution, any objections received would require the proposal to
return to council before the rezoning is finalised.


Got something you want to say about this story? Have your say on our opinion and comment hub, North Coast Times Engage